AtS 5x17 "Underneath" -- some answers, please?

[chicken]

In this scene where the Fang Gang comes to rescuse Lindsey, he mentions his "speeding tickets" and some guy Fisher, and his son playing hockey, and some "league" that he's in.

Now, I know this is a massively stupid question, but do you folks think he really ever lives any of that stuff? Does he really ever leave the house and go bowling with some guy named Fisher and get a speeding ticket on the way home? Does he go to 'work'? Does he see his 'son' play hockey? And only once every three or four days have his heart cut out?

Or does he never make it past 8:00 am? In this scenario, he just gets up, helps his son with some homework, goes downstairs, gets his heart cut out, and then the magic spell (or whatever it is) kicks in and he's back in bed ready to start over. Maybe they let him sleep for a few hours to lull him back into the thrall. In this scenario, all that other stuff, the speeding tickets and hockey games and free vacation contests are all just implanted memories (like people's fake memories of Dawn or Connor's new life 'memories').

Which scenario is more plausible?